“Who is filming that?”
It’s a question I often ask myself as I’m watching videos online. You know the ones, filmed so that you feel like a bystander watching as if this is normal life, and then something funny or embarrassing or heartfelt or outrageous happens. But I find myself thinking, why was someone filming at that exact moment? Did they just happen to be recording a video and accidentally catch something that turned out to be internet-worthy?
The number of times I have tried and failed to video my kids doing something funny/adorable in everyday life, tells me people must be either recording every moment of their life to accidentally catch something amazing…or, it is set up. Which, of course, most video content on the internet is.
You may be familiar with recent story about the women receiving flowers as a random act of kindness, which was filmed without her consent and became a viral TikTok video. Or the guy who was just trying to go to Coles for some food and became famous because someone sneakily paid for his groceries.
It’s been a trend for a while now, where a benevolent individual is generous to the unknowing and ‘sad’ public, so they can experience a glimpse of hope in their otherwise ‘depressing’ lives, all whilst being secretly filmed. The ‘joy’ that it brings is multiplied by the millions of views the video gets and we can all feel a little bit better about the good in the world, as the creator earns something from their kind act, be that money, followers, fame etc.
It begs the question, if an act of generosity isn’t filmed and posted, did it even happen?
But generosity is generosity, right? What does it matter that millions of people have consumed it?
Yeah, I’m not sure where I land on this. Is it okay or not?
Here’s why it could be okay:
- It’s just a video of a young guy giving someone flowers, or a dude paying for someone’s food
- It promotes generosity
- Random acts of kindness are awesome
- We should make generous people famous for what they do. Bad news travels fast, good news usually doesn’t – lets celebrate it when it does.
Here is why it is not okay:
- Clearly, these videos are not about the recipient of the gift at all. Part of generosity is giving something that is helpful to the recipient, not an act that dehumanises them in the process as the video becomes viral distorts the real story of the individual
- It reduces the recipient to a product that is consumed. That is not dignifying. Generosity builds people up, empowers them and provides dignity.
- Like actual pornography, it’s a cheap knock off of the real thing, created only for the end viewer/customer at the cost of those involved.
In any act of generosity, the giver will always get something out of it, that is part of the beauty of it. But when it ends up that the giver gets more out of it than the person on the receiving end, be that likes, follows, views, attention, fame, or money, then it ceases to be a generous act and becomes manipulation for profit.
So, the safest way to be generous is to do in intentionally, thoughtfully and as often as you can, without uploading it to the internet.